Treasury proposes rule to implement GENIUS Act’s requirements on US issuance, offer and sale
Treasury has proposed a rule implementing Section 3 of the GENIUS Act, which determines who may issue, offer and sell payment stablecoins in the United States. The proposal would implement a direct U.S. issuance path for qualifying foreign issuers, offer location-based safe harbors and make digital asset service providers gatekeepers for foreign-issued stablecoins.
The Treasury Department proposed a rule to implement Section 3 of the GENIUS Act (the “Section 3 NPRM”), including the Act’s prohibitions and limits on payment stablecoin issuance, offer and sale in the United States. The Section 3 NPRM will shape the scope of the permitted payment stablecoin marketplace in the United States.
Introduction
Section 3 of the GENIUS Act specifies who can participate in the payment stablecoin marketplace in the United States. It includes three key components:
- Section 3(a) prohibits any person other than a permitted payment stablecoin issuer (“PPSI”) from issuing a payment stablecoin in the United States. Knowing participation in a violation is punishable by a fine of up to $1 million per violation, imprisonment of up to five years or both.
- Section 3(b) prohibits any digital asset service provider (“DASP”) from (1) offering or selling a non-PPSI-issued payment stablecoin to a person in the United States beginning July 18, 2028 and (2) offering, selling or otherwise making available a payment stablecoin issued by a foreign payment stablecoin issuer (“FPSI”) in the United States once the Act is effective on January 18, 2027 unless the FPSI has the technological capability to comply, and will comply, with lawful orders and reciprocal arrangements.[1]
- Section 3(c) empowers the Treasury Secretary to issue regulations providing for limited safe harbors from the above prohibitions, including for a de minimis volume of transactions and in unusual and exigent circumstances.
Section 5(f) of the GENIUS Act authorizes the primary federal payment stablecoin regulators to waive the application of the GENIUS Act’s requirements (including Section 3) for up to 12 months for subsidiaries of insured depository institutions and federal qualified payment stablecoin issuers with a pending application to become PPSIs on the GENIUS Act’s effective date.
The Section 3 NPRM would implement these provisions by adopting, as a new 12 C.F.R. part 1523, various definitions, the substantive issuance and offer and sale prohibitions, related exemptions and safe harbors and an appendix of interpretations addressing common fact patterns, as summarized below. The proposed regulations would define the basic rules and roles that will underpin the regulated payment stablecoin marketplace in the United States. For background on the GENIUS Act and the status of its implementation, see our client updates on the Act’s enactment, on implementation after one year and on the OCC’s final rule.[2]
Treasury considered modeling important components of the Section 3 NPRM around existing regimes, particularly those that govern the issuance and marketing of securities and commodities in the United States. However, it declined to repurpose such regimes given the differences between payment stablecoins and securities and other financial instruments, namely their use for payment rather than investment and unique features of their operational mechanics (e.g., minting and redemption), as well as the GENIUS Act’s express provision that payment stablecoins are not securities or commodities. Accordingly, if the Section 3 NPRM is adopted as proposed, reasoning by analogy from securities practice likely would be of only limited use in resolving interpretive questions. Although certain elements of the Section 3 NPRM borrow concepts from the SEC’s Regulation S, Treasury states that it does not intend to incorporate Regulation S or its interpretations. Treasury has, however, asked whether it should instead adopt a framework more closely modeled on Regulation S, as discussed below.
Key definitions
The Section 3 NPRM proposes definitions of several key terms that would determine the reach of the proposal’s prohibitions. These definitions would apply only for purposes of part 1523; for example, they would not necessarily govern the calculation of outstanding issuance under the federal banking agencies’ prudential rules.
- DASP would be defined via cross reference to the statutory definition in the GENIUS Act—which would generally capture exchanges, facilitators of digital asset transfers, custodians and financial services providers acting with respect to digital assets—but with the added clarification that the term includes any person that, for compensation or profit, engages in the business in the United States of issuing payment stablecoins. Treasury reasons that core issuer activities fall within the DASP definition; for example, when redeeming a payment stablecoin, an issuer necessarily exchanges a digital asset for monetary value. As a result, PPSIs (and FPSIs that issue in the United States) would themselves be subject to the DASP offer and sale prohibitions with respect to other issuers’ payment stablecoins that they offer, sell or make available.
- Issuer would be defined as a person who (i) is obligated to convert, redeem, or repurchase the payment stablecoin for a fixed amount of monetary value, and (ii) represents that the person will maintain, or creates the reasonable expectation that the person will maintain, a stable value relative to the value of a fixed amount of monetary value. Persons that participate in issuance but do not perform these functions, such as a technical service provider that mints the payment stablecoin or a brand partner in a white label arrangement, would not be treated as an issuer, although they could still face criminal liability for knowingly participating in an unlawful issuance (discussed below). Treasury asks whether either prong alone (e.g., a redemption obligation) should suffice and whether the definition should also include a minting prong. The Section 3 NPRM also contemplates, but does not take a definitive view on, the possibility of the proposed definition resulting in multiple issuers for the same payment stablecoin.
- Issue would be defined as the first transfer of a payment stablecoin by the issuer, except as required by a lawful order, whether directly or indirectly, including by crediting an account, that results or will result in a person other than the issuer having the right to use or transfer the payment stablecoin or to have the payment stablecoin converted, redeemed, or repurchased.
- A digital asset that has been minted but is held in the issuer’s treasury would not be considered to have been issued, but minting into a customer wallet (even if hosted by the issuer) would be treated as an issuance.
- An issuer’s first transfer of a payment stablecoin after redeeming or otherwise reacquiring it would be a new issuance, as would a first transfer effected indirectly through an agent or intermediary, such as an underwriter or distributor.
- A right to redeem the payment stablecoin need not be immediate, for example if there is a redemption lockout period. Consequently, an unlicensed issuer could not avoid the prohibition by distributing tokens subject to a redemption lockout while awaiting authorization. Treasury separately asks whether transfers without a sale, such as airdrops, should be treated as issuances.[3]
- The definition of “issue” is significantly informed by the Uniform Commercial Code (“UCC”). Treasury noted that the UCC’s treatment of negotiable instruments and transfer of controllable electronic records are both analogically relevant sources of insight in interpreting terms in the payment stablecoin context, although Treasury does not take a position on the UCC treatment of payment stablecoin transactions.
- Offer would be defined via cross reference to the GENIUS Act but with the added clarification that “the term includes making available for purchase, sale, or exchange a payment stablecoin that has not yet been issued.” The Section 3 NPRM states that Treasury interprets the definition to include presales of payment stablecoins that have not yet been issued.
- Lawful order would be defined by cross reference to the GENIUS Act—generally, a final and valid order issued under federal law by a court or authorized federal agency that requires the issuer to seize, freeze, burn or prevent the transfer of its payment stablecoins, identifies the affected payment stablecoins or accounts with reasonable particularity and is subject to judicial or administrative review. Treasury asks whether the definition should be aligned more closely with the definition in FinCEN’s proposed AML/CFT program rule for PPSIs.
- Located in the United States would be defined:
- for legal entities, as the entity being either organized in a U.S. jurisdiction or having its principal place of business in the United States; and
- for individuals, as being physically present in the United States except if the individual is a non-resident and their physical presence is merely temporary. Conversely, a U.S. resident who is temporarily abroad would not be located in the United States. The Section 3 NPRM does not specify standards for residence or temporary presence, although Treasury asks whether it should.
Key provisions
- Issuance by a non-PPSI/certain FPSIs: If the Section 3 NPRM is adopted as proposed, it would be unlawful for anyone other than a PPSI or an FPSI meeting the criteria of Section 18(a) of the GENIUS Act to issue a payment stablecoin if, at the time of issuance, either the issuer or the person to whom the payment stablecoin is issued is located in the United States (as defined above). Section 18(a) requires, among other things, that the FPSI be subject to a home country regime that Treasury has determined to be comparable to the GENIUS Act and that it register with the OCC (a “Comparably Regulated FPSI”). The OCC’s registration requirements for FPSIs are summarized in our client update here.[4]
- An issuer not organized in a U.S. jurisdiction and with a principal place of business outside the United States would be deemed not to issue a payment stablecoin in the United States—even if it inadvertently issues to a person located in the United States—if it:
- reasonably believes each person to whom the payment stablecoin is issued is not located in the United States;
- has adopted and implemented policies, procedures and controls reasonably designed to avoid issuing the payment stablecoin to any person located in the United States; and
- does not engage in advertising or solicitation activities that target, or could be reasonably expected to have the effect of targeting, any person located in the United States.
- Treasury explains that an issuer could not have a reasonable belief if it knows, has reason to know or should know that a recipient is located in the United States, and that its policies, procedures and controls must be implemented in practice and periodically updated (e.g., in response to any inadvertent issuance to a person located in the United States).
- The Section 3 NPRM provides three non-exhaustive examples of “participating” in an unlawful issuance for purposes of the GENIUS Act’s criminal penalties:
- incurring a primary or secondary (e.g., guarantee) obligation to redeem the payment stablecoin;
- coordinating with the issuer to facilitate key steps in the issuance, such as soliciting customers or minting (which could capture a brand partner in a white label arrangement); and
- acting as a market maker for, distributing or otherwise making available for secondary market trading newly issued payment stablecoins (e.g., a DASP listing the payment stablecoin shortly after issuance).
- An issuer not organized in a U.S. jurisdiction and with a principal place of business outside the United States would be deemed not to issue a payment stablecoin in the United States—even if it inadvertently issues to a person located in the United States—if it:
Treasury generally does not intend the third example to capture purchases for a purchaser’s own use or secondary market trading without a close temporal nexus to the issuance, although such trading may implicate the offer and sale prohibitions discussed below.
- Treasury declined to interpret Section 3(a) of the GENIUS Act, which refers only to issuance by PPSIs, to prohibit issuance in the United States by Comparably Regulated FPSIs. Treasury grounded this reading principally in the text of Section 18(a), which disapplies the “prohibitions under section 3” to qualifying FPSIs, and Section 4(a)(12)(C), which contemplates certain foreign companies issuing payment stablecoins with Stablecoin Certification Review Committee approval. Treasury also articulated a policy view that prohibiting direct issuance would force inefficient workaround structures (e.g., issuance to an offshore intermediary that then sells into the United States), potentially obscure key steps in the creation of payment stablecoins from U.S. regulators and create an uneven playing field between PPSIs and Comparably Regulated FPSIs. This cross-border-friendly policy stance informs much of the Section 3 NPRM.
- Treasury requests comment on two alternative approaches: (1) a stricter approach under which any issuance to a person located in the United States would be unlawful regardless of the issuer’s diligence, with knowledge relevant only to criminal liability; and (2) an offshore transaction framework more closely modeled on Regulation S, which would incorporate a “directed selling efforts” concept and, for entity acquirers, look to where the transaction instruction originates (e.g., an authorized employee acting from abroad) rather than to the entity’s domicile.
- Offer or sale of payment stablecoins by DASPs: Under the GENIUS Act, beginning on July 18, 2028, it is unlawful for a DASP to offer or sell a payment stablecoin to a person located in the United States unless the payment stablecoin is issued by a PPSI or a Comparably Regulated FPSI. Beginning on the GENIUS Act’s effective date of January 18, 2027, it will also be unlawful for a DASP to offer, sell or otherwise make available in the United States a payment stablecoin issued by an FPSI unless the FPSI has the technological capability to comply, and will comply, with the terms of any lawful order and any reciprocal arrangement under Section 18 of the Act. A DASP may rely on an FPSI’s representation that the FPSI has the technological capability to comply, and will comply, with lawful orders and reciprocal arrangements if the DASP has conducted reasonable due diligence, unless the DASP knows, has reason to know or should know that the representation is false. In Treasury’s view, this requirement applies even to payment stablecoins issued by Comparably Regulated FPSIs.
- The Section 3 NPRM provides examples of an offer or sale to a person in the United States, which include direct solicitation, advertising the payment stablecoin as available for purchase in the United States, positively responding to an unsolicited inquiry from a person in the United States and advising potential purchasers on how to evade location detection or restriction mechanisms (e.g., IP address blocking). Treating a positive response to an unsolicited inquiry as an offer would be a notable departure from the reverse solicitation concepts available under certain other U.S. regimes.
- Entering into a contract to sell the payment stablecoin to a person located in the United States is an offer or sale even if the person will be outside of the United States for delivery.
- However, a DASP would be deemed not to violate these prohibitions if it
- reasonably believes the person to whom the payment stablecoin is made available is not located in the United States;
- has adopted and implemented policies, procedures and controls reasonably designed to avoid offering, selling or making available the payment stablecoin to any person located in the United States; and
- does not engage in advertising or solicitation activities that target, or could be reasonably expected to have the effect of targeting, any person located in the United States.
- Exemptions and safe harbors: The Section 3 NPRM would implement (1) a safe harbor from the issuance and offer and sale prohibitions for a subsidiary of an insured depository institution or a federal qualified payment stablecoin issuer with a pending PPSI application on the GENIUS Act’s effective date, but only if its primary federal payment stablecoin regulator grants a waiver under Section 5(f); (2) any limited safe harbors the Treasury Secretary may provide in unusual and exigent circumstances; and (3) the GENIUS Act’s statutory exemptions for direct transfers between two individuals acting on their own behalf without an intermediary, transfers between an individual’s U.S. and non-U.S. accounts offered by the same parent company and transactions using software or hardware wallets that facilitate self-custody. Treasury did not propose a de minimis safe harbor but asks whether additional safe harbors should be adopted. For a discussion of the OCC’s proposed Section 5(f) waiver process, see our client update[5] on the OCC’s GENIUS Act final rule.
Practical impact
Most of the restrictions in proposed 12 C.F.R. part 1523 would not be implicated by payment stablecoins issued by PPSIs or Comparably Regulated FPSIs (although, in Treasury’s view, the lawful order condition in Section 3(b)(2) applies to all FPSI-issued payment stablecoins). Thus, DASPs that deal only with payment stablecoins issued by such entities will face a less complex regulatory environment than if dealing with payment stablecoins issued by other persons.
The timing of the two DASP prohibitions creates near-term pressure. The lawful order condition in Section 3(b)(2) applies from the GENIUS Act’s effective date of January 18, 2027, and because the standard is forward-looking (the FPSI “will comply”), the due diligence supporting reliance on an FPSI’s representations will likely need to be refreshed over time rather than performed once at listing. DASPs that make FPSI-issued payment stablecoins available in the United States may wish to begin obtaining and documenting these representations now.
At the same time, the Section 18(a) pathway is not yet operational. To date, Treasury has not determined that any foreign regime is comparable to the GENIUS Act, and it has not proposed rules governing that process. Until it does, FPSIs would have no direct U.S. issuance path, and unless determinations are made before July 18, 2028, DASPs would be unable to offer or sell FPSI-issued payment stablecoins to persons located in the United States. Treasury’s accompanying regulatory impact analysis assumes that certain major foreign-issued stablecoins will not qualify and that U.S.-facing platforms will need to restrict trading in them.
The Section 3 NPRM would also have consequences beyond issuers. Because PPSIs would themselves be DASPs, a PPSI that lists, distributes or custodies other issuers’ payment stablecoins would need to apply the offer and sale prohibitions to those payment stablecoins. For example, if a national trust bank is a PPSI and also offers digital asset custody services, those custody services would need to comply with the offer and sale prohibitions. Market makers, distributors, exchanges and white label brand partners should consider diligence on the regulatory status of payment stablecoins they support at or around issuance, given the proposed examples of participating in an unlawful issuance. And non-U.S. issuers and DASPs relying on the proposed safe harbors should expect to need robust location controls, given the absence of a reverse solicitation exception.
More broadly, the Section 3 NPRM reflects Treasury’s effort to balance the primacy of the U.S. regulatory framework with openness to a global payment stablecoin market. The approach articulated in the Section 3 NPRM may shape other GENIUS Act implementation, including Treasury’s comparability determinations and its statutory directive to pursue reciprocal arrangements with other jurisdictions.
[1] Section 18(a) of the GENIUS Act exempts certain FPSIs from the Section 3 prohibitions if, among other things, the FPSI is subject to regulation and supervision by a foreign payment stablecoin regulator of a foreign country that has a regulatory and supervisory regime with respect to payment stablecoins that the Secretary of the Treasury determines is comparable to the regime established under the GENIUS Act and the FPSI is registered with the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”).
[3] Interpretation 2 of the Section 3 NPRM would, if adopted as proposed, consider an airdrop to a U.S. resident who is physically present in the United States and who will have the right to transfer, use, or redeem the payment stablecoin to be an issuance of the payment stablecoin.
This communication, which we believe may be of interest to our clients and friends of the firm, is for general information only. It is not a full analysis of the matters presented and should not be relied upon as legal advice. This may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions. Please refer to the firm’s privacy notice for further details.